• Academy
    • What we do
      • About acatech
      • Mission
      • Guidelines for Advising Policymakers and the Public
      • Patron
    • Organisation
      • Overview
      • Members
      • Senate
      • Executive Board
      • Management Board
      • Board of Trustees
      • Topic networks
      • Quality management
    • Secretariat
      • Team (German)
      • Jobs (German)
      • Locations
  • Topics
    • Biotechnology
    • Digital & Self-learning
    • Energy & Resources
    • Healthcare Technologies
    • Innovation
    • Mobility
    • Security
    • Technology & Society
    • Work & Education
  • International Cooperation
    • European Science Advice for Policy
    • International Relations
    • Events
  • Projects
  • Publications
  • Media
    • News
    • Media Library
    • Ask acatech
    • Subscriptions
    • How we communicate – guidelines and initiatives
  • DE
  • Academy
    • What we do
      • About acatech
      • Mission
      • Guidelines for Advising Policymakers and the Public
      • Patron
    • Organisation
      • Overview
      • Members
      • Senate
      • Executive Board
      • Management Board
      • Board of Trustees
      • Topic networks
      • Quality management
    • Secretariat
      • Team (German)
      • Jobs (German)
      • Locations
  • Topics
    • Biotechnology
    • Digital & Self-learning
    • Energy & Resources
    • Healthcare Technologies
    • Innovation
    • Mobility
    • Security
    • Technology & Society
    • Work & Education
  • International Cooperation
    • European Science Advice for Policy
    • International Relations
    • Events
  • Projects
  • Publications
  • Media
    • News
    • Media Library
    • Ask acatech
    • Subscriptions
    • How we communicate – guidelines and initiatives
  • DE

Quality Criteria in the Technological Sciences

Download PDF (German)
Download PDF Summary (English)

Author / Publisher: acatech
Format: acatech POSITION PAPER
Published: 26 April 2018

At a glance

The acatech POSITION PAPER presents the first ever set of quality criteria for the  technological sciences as a whole. They are directed at universities and other research institutions, research policymakers and research funding agencies. The key criteria are as follows:

  • Publications are only of limited value for quantitative performance evaluation in the technological sciences.
  • No distinction should be drawn between public and private funding when it comes to successfully secured third-party funding.
  • Doctorates – often in collaboration with industry – account for a significant proportion of research. A high number of doctorates and postdoctoral qualifications should be evaluated positively.
  • Licences are an indication that innovations have been successfully marketed and should therefore receive a higher weighting than patents.
  • Participation in large, established research partnerships should be promoted.
  • Innovation prizes indicate that the research in question has practical relevance.

Methodological approach

The quality criteria set out in the acatech POSITION PAPER are the result of a broad consultation process within the technological sciences. As well as representatives of the key technological science fields, the project group also included social scientists and humanities scholars engaged in research into the technological sciences. The interim findings were discussed by a wide group of experts and stakeholders from academia and industry.

  • Contact

    PD Dr. Marc-Denis Weitze
    acatech Geschäftsstelle
    Tel.: +49 89 520309-50
    weitze@acatech.de

  • Projects

    Assessment criteria for the technological sciences and appointments in the technological sciences

  • Topic

    Work & Education

    Technology & Society

Newsletter TRANSFER

Our monthly newsletter TRANSFER (available only in German) keeps you up to date with the academy’s current themes, projects and events.

If you do NOT wish to receive our newsletter in the future, you can unsubscribe here.

  • Social Media




  • Academy

    • What we do
    • Topics
    • Members
    • Senate
    • Executive Board
    • Management Board
    • Secretariat (German)
    • Jobs (German)
    • Locations
  • Legal notices

    • Imprint
    • Privacy policy
  • Contact

    acatech – National Academy
    of Science and Engineering

    Munich Office
    Karolinenplatz 4
    80333 Munich
    Germany

    +49 (0)89/52 03 09-0
    info@acatech.de

© 2019 acatech - National Academy of Science and Engineering